He was convicted of first degree murder and was sentenced to life without parole. A British convicted murderer and sex offender. Nilsen's trial judge originally recommended a 25-year minimum sentence in November 1983, but successive Home Secretaries decided that he should never be released from prison. If he really did kill 11 people, he would hold the grisly title of Britain's fifth most prolific serial killer behind Dr Harold Shipman, Dennis Nilsen, Peter Sutcliffe and Fred and Rose West. Convicted of the murder of William Straight. At a commutation hearing in 2021, Johnson alleged that the victim man had called him a racial slur and reached for a gun. Allegations have been made that O'Neill also murdered a number of other children in several Australian states from the mid-1960s whilst he was still a teenager through to the murder that he was imprisoned for in 1975. Her release plan had included a requirement to live in designated accommodation as well as strict curbs on her contacts, movements and activities. In 2014, the killer took part in a programme to help her with her decision-making but admitted to the parole panel that she had told facilitators "what she thought they wanted to hear". Died in prison. 62-year-old convicted murderer Matthews was sentenced to a whole life term on 9 January 2015, after pleading guilty to the murder of healthcare assistant Sharon Wall at Wotton Hill Hospital in. He had several previous convictions for gross indecency against Keighley and sexual assault against other teenage girls, one of which he had been in prison for. Read about our approach to external linking. Reputed to be the longest surviving prisoner in. Before the law lords' ruling in November 2002, Bamber was told by at least one Home Secretary that his life sentence would mean life. Sentenced to death for a fatal bank robbery when she was 17 years old, commuted to life in prison without parole in 1972. He had previously served 15 years in prison in Germany for murdering another ex-girlfriend and was deported to the UK in January 2008. Maria Pearson, now 66, will be told within weeks if she is to be unleashed for the 1986 slaying of Janet Newton. Both murderers have been issued 40-year minimum terms by the High Court, which means that they are likely to remain imprisoned for most if not all of their remaining lives, while many other prisoners are in a similar position due to the length of their minimum terms and the age they will be when they can be considered for parole. However, he was mistakenly transferred to prison rather than released, and forgotten about until 2005. WebMassey in 2022 John Massey (born 1948) is an English former prisoner who was the longest-serving prisoner in the United Kingdom, having been imprisoned for nearly 43 years by the time he was paroled. Juvenile lifer in the state of Michigan who at the age of 16 along with three other male teens forced their way into Minnie Peapples Benton Harbor home seeking money. Convicted in 2011 of the premeditated murder of 89-year-old Florence Habesch in February that year to fund his drug addiction. View our online Press Pack. In 2014 she took part in a programme to help her with her decision-making but admitted to the parole panel she had told facilitators "what she thought they wanted to hear". [110], Fellows was also found guilty of shooting dead John Kinsella, a friend of Massey from Liverpool, three years later. Nilsen was also denied the right to publish his, A fugitive who in 1983 gatecrashed a wedding reception at a house in. - Free Online Library", "Stourport man handed life for 'horrific murder' has appeal rejected", "Couple murdered pensioner then toasted it with champagne", "John Gogarty Wombwell murder: Ian Birley and Helen Nichols jailed", "HMP Long Lartin prisoner sentenced for inmate's murder", "Christopher Halliwell admits Sian O'Callaghan murder", "Inside story: How a resourceful detective got Chris Halliwell to confess but fell foul of the law", "Halliwell: Why Second Murder Charge Was Dropped", "Man found guilty of Becky Godden murder", "Taxi driver Chris Halliwell given full life term for Becky Godden murder", "Sian Blake death: Arthur Simpson-Kent given life sentence", "Sian Blake EastEnders case: Man charged with family murders", "Sentencing Remarks of Mr Justice Wilkie", "Stephen Port: Serial killer guilty of murdering four men", "R v Stephen Port: Sentencing Remarks of Mr Justice Openshaw", "Serial killer Port given whole life term", "Man who murdered nurse in her own home will NEVER be released", "Jailed: London man who stabbed girlfriend to death while she slept", "Derbyshire child rapist jailed for life", "Child rapist jailed for life - Uppal Taylor Solicitors", "Whole-life jail term for second killing", https://www.judiciary.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/r-v-unwin-and-mcfall-sentencing.pdf, "William McFall and Stephen Unwin sentence: Every update as monstrous murderers told they will never be released", "Killer gets whole-life term for sex attacks", "Mark Fellows: how Salford hitman evaded police for gangland murders", "Gangland hitman fails in appeal against 'excessive' life sentence", "Reading stabbings: Terror suspect Khairi Saadallah appears at Old Bailey", "Reading stabbings: Khairi Saadallah jailed for park murders", "Forbury Gardens stabbings: Killer sentenced to whole-life order for 'ruthless and brutal' attack", "Sarah Everard murder: Wayne Couzens handed whole-life sentence", "Wayne Couzens, killer of Sarah Everard, fails in bid to have whole life sentence cut as double murderer Ian Stewart has his decreased", "David Fuller: Killer who abused mortuary bodies will die in jail", "Anthony Russell: Triple killer given whole-life prison sentence", "Isis supporting terrorist given whole life sentence for 'shameless' murder of MP", "Sir David Amess stabbing: What we know so far", Sir David Amess murder: Ali Harbi Ali given whole-life sentence, "Reading flats fire: Hakeem Kigundu jailed for double-murder", "Killamarsh deaths: Damien Bendall who murdered pregnant woman and three children sentenced to whole life prison term", "Repatriation for Balcombe Street gang now likely", "Balcombe St and Gerry Conlon Joe O'Connell's Speech from the Dock", "Crime Files Reopened: The Anglesey double murderer who may never be released", "Sex killer fails in bid to cut 35-year term", "Outrage over Beckton child killer's freedom bid", "Sarah Payne killer to serve 50-year term", "Sarah Payne killer Roy Whiting's prison term reduced", "Judges quash 'whole-life' sentence for builder who murdered three", "Murderer's 'whole life' sentence overturned", "Cannibal's life sentence 'no consolation to us', "Danilo Restivo guilty of teenager murder", "Whole life prison terms upheld by Court of Appeal", "Bermondsey rapist Michael Roberts jailed for life", "Notorious East Lancashire killer Anthony Entwistle loses bid for freedom", "Double killer and violent rapist wins appeal against 'too harsh' life sentence", "Triple baby killer may go to open prison", "Mum's fury as triple killer who murdered his own babies granted open prison move", "Man who killed author guilty of murdering wife", "Double murderer Ian Stewart has whole life order reduced", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_prisoners_with_whole_life_orders&oldid=1140406982, Prisoners sentenced to life imprisonment by the United Kingdom, All articles with bare URLs for citations, Articles with bare URLs for citations from March 2022, Articles with PDF format bare URLs for citations, Short description is different from Wikidata, Articles needing additional references from September 2009, All articles needing additional references, Articles with unsourced statements from September 2022, Articles with unsourced statements from August 2020, Articles with unsourced statements from July 2021, Wikipedia articles in need of updating from May 2021, All Wikipedia articles in need of updating, All articles with specifically marked weasel-worded phrases, Articles with specifically marked weasel-worded phrases from January 2022, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0. Kunowski murdered a 12-year-old. Duncan featured in a 2014 news report about his human rights potentially being breached. BRITAINS longest-serving prisoner the serial killer Patrick MacKay is to make a bid for freedom within weeks. Then Paid for It", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_longest_prison_sentences_served&oldid=1142308978, Short description is different from Wikidata, Articles needing additional references from September 2022, All articles needing additional references, Articles with failed verification from March 2021, Articles with failed verification from September 2022, Articles with unsourced statements from March 2021, Articles lacking reliable references from March 2021, Articles with unsourced statements from March 2022, Articles with unsourced statements from November 2020, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0. Placed in solitary confinement for the murder of the same corrections officer as Woodfox. In 2008 Reynolds tried to strangle a girl, but this merely resulted in a final warning when police investigated. He was alleged to have eaten part of the brain of one of three men he killed in prison, which earned him the nickname "Hannibal the Cannibal" among the British press. In August 1976 he confessed to both murders and also to that of Janet Lesley Stewart who until then had been a missing person. Was convicted in August 2006 of the two murders, while being suspected of a third one, a firefighter in Glasgow. His victims were 80-year-old Doris Dawson, her 34-year-old daughter Mandy Power and her two granddaughters, 10-year-old Katie and 8-year-old Emily, by beating them with a pole and then setting the house on fire where their bodies were discovered by firefighters and the trial judge said that the "exceptional savagery" of the murders meant that Morris should never be released. Multiple child killer. Man held in preventive prison for the longest time in the world: sentence was imposed for assaulting five boys. United States. Follow BBC North East & Cumbria on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram. Longest held prisoner on death row in Texas. His trial judge said that he found the idea of ever seeing Bamber free again "difficult to foresee", and advised that he should serve at least 25 years behind bars before release could even be considered. To see all content on The Sun, please use the Site Map. For other inquiries, Contact Us. BRITAIN'S longest-serving prisoner could finally be freed after serving 35-years for a savage jealousy-fuelled murder. He was ordered to be detained indefinitely in 1967 after he indecently assaulted, stabbed and strangled a five-year-old girl. It followed bullying and intimidation allegations two years earlier at an open prison. Released in 2013, when he had advanced, Placed in solitary confinement after pleading guilty to murdering. Britain's longest-serving female prisoner who has been locked up since 1987 and dubbed UK's 'forgotten inmate' could finally be freed - 37 YEARS after murdering her In October 1986, he was found guilty of shooting dead his adoptive parents, sister and six-year-old twin nephews at the family farmhouse in Essex 14 months earlier, in order to claim a six-figure inheritance while also laying evidence to suggest his sister, a known schizophrenic, had committed the murders before killing herself. Palestinian with Jordanian citizenship who. The monster - who has changed his name to David Groves - could be freed as he was moved to an open prison in 2017. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. He had previously developed an obsession with violent pornography and images of extreme child abuse. [2][3] These include some of Britain's most notorious criminals, including the serial murderer Rosemary West. [11][13] He spoke to the BBC World Service about his life in May 2021.[14]. Imprisoned for shooting a man in an argument over a cigarette in a, Killed a pregnant woman and her 3-year-old daughter, and wounded her 4-year-old son, during a shooting spree in. Sentenced in 1967 for two counts of first-degree murder and one count of attempted first-degree murder. Convicted alongside Gary Smith for the February 2013 murder of convicted child killer Subhan Anwar in his cell at HMP Long Lartin. The sentencing judge, Mr Justice Wall, described Russell as "exceptionally dangerous and manipulative". UK's longest-serving female prisoner could walk free 37 years after murdering exs lover Maria Pearson has been in jail since 1987 for the jealous-fuelled murder of Janet Newton. EXCLUSIVE. Couzens, a serving, David Fuller was sentenced to life imprisonment with a whole life order on 15 December 2021 for the murders of Wendy Knell, 25, and Caroline Pearce, 20, in. Originally sentenced to life in prison for murder when he was 16 years old, he was sent to. In 1977 he and David Cheeseman took fellow patient David Francis hostage and tortured him to death and as a result was convicted of manslaughter and sent to Wakefield prison. Maria Pearson, now 66, will be told within A court tossed his sentence Wednesday for faulty jury instructions", "Texas Department of Criminal Justice Offender Search", https://www.ahwatukee.com/news/valley_and_state/image_593f4393-c500-59d6-a60b-20150b56b55d.html, https://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/murray-hooper-arizona-set-to-execute-man-in-1980-killings-of-2-people, "Askari Abdullah Muhammad, aka Thomas Knight, executed after 40 years", "Cabdriver killer Carey Dean Moore recounted how he got to death row", "Tennessee executes longest serving death row inmate after 36 years", "Judge issues death warrant for Idaho death row inmate Gerald Pizzuto", "They Are Terminally Ill. States Want To Execute Them Anyway", "Dying Idaho inmate's execution is canceled, with clemency hearing granted by state panel", "Federal appeals court allows Ohio to move forward with execution after failed attempt", "Appeals court OKs 2nd execution attempt for Ohio man", "Inmate who survived execution attempt dies; COVID suspected", "Arizona executes 71-year-old Edward Schad, its oldest death row inmate", "Edward Harold Schad Jr., oldest Ariz. death row inmate, executed for 1978 murder", "Gov. Hindley's trial judge recommended she should serve at least 25 years in prison, feeling that unlike Brady there was a possibility that Hindley could be rehabilitated and suitable for parole - once removed from Brady's influence. The UK's longest-serving female prisoner has been denied parole for the ninth time. Griffin beat, stabbed and sexually assaulted Peapples, who bled to death after the teens fled for which Griffin was sentenced to life without parole until he was resentenced on July 10, 2017, to 40 to 60 years and he was paroled on June 6, 2018. The 70-year-old is one of the UK's longest serving prisoners, having first been sent to Walton Jail, officially known as HMP Liverpool, in 1974. WebJohn Thomas Straffen (27 February 1930 19 November 2007) was a British serial killer who was the longest-serving prisoner in British history. His first victim was widow Isabella Griffiths, 87, who was strangled and stabbed at her home in Chelsea. This recommendation was upheld when the list of confirmed whole-life tariff prisoners was published, and Hall was the oldest prisoner on the list. Found guilty of murdering his wife Hazel, having stabbed her to death and chopped her body into 16 pieces at their home in Redditch, Worcestershire in the previous year. After receiving a life release from jail in 1975, he found employment as an electrician in Bristol and was married a second time. Copeland can only be released after 50 years if considered not to be dangerous at that point. Convicted of the execution-style murder of Neville Corby (aged 42) with a shotgun and the simultaneous attempted murder of Corby's partner. Placed in solitary confinement for the murder of a corrections officer. [5], Successive Home Secretaries are known to have imposed whole life orders for at least 23 murderers between 1983 and 2002 (note, this list is incomplete). BRITAINS longest-serving prisoner could finally be freed after serving 35-years for a savage jealousy-fuelled murder. The UKs longest-serving female prisoner has been denied parole for a ninth time. The Judge said that he had carried out the murders to "satisfy his lust for sex with young men who were rendered unconscious" and gave him a whole-life term. Despite the fact that ministers can no longer set sentences they still retain the power to release a prisoner during their sentences on compassionate grounds, normally exercised only when a prisoner is terminally ill. Several months before ministers were stripped of their powers to set minimum sentences, the High Court also stripped ministers of their power to overrule the Parole Board's decision that a life sentence prisoner can be paroled. Convicted for three of the murders, he was given three consecutive life terms without parole. The killer, also known as the Devils Disciple, split the skull of a priest in half with an axe, and strangled and stabbed two elderly women. Inmate in Wisconsin who was sentenced in 1967. Spent 66 years in prison in Louisiana, beginning when he was 17 and ending with his death at 83. Involuntarily committed when he was 17 after a sex offense in which the victim was a minor. John Massey is a 74-year-old convicted killer and one of Britain's longest-serving prisoners. Was jailed for life at the age of 16 for the murder of a 50-year-old man during a home invasion. Sentenced to life in prison for aggravated assault, non-capital murder, overcoming resistance, possessing a weapon or imitation, and public mischief and robbery. Placed in solitary confinement for the same murder as Woodfox and Wallace, until his original conviction was overturned. BRITAINS longest-serving prisoner the serial killer Patrick MacKay is to make a bid for freedom within weeks. [32], Shipman's suicide may have been motivated by the desire to leave his wife with a full NHS pension of a 100,000 lump-sum payment plus 1,200 per month for life, as his wife would only receive this if he died before the age of 60 (he committed suicide a day before his 58th birthday). Culshaw was found collapsed in his cell at Frankland Prison on 5 February 2013 and died the following day in hospital apparently of natural causes, aged 45. John Childs was convicted of the murder of six people in contract killings which were committed between 1974 and 1978; he implicated two others and they were convicted in 1980, but they were released on appeal in 2003 after his evidence was called into question. The term was reset in 1997 to the original 25 years, which was reduced again to 23 years in 2006. Convicted of murdering a young mother and her in-laws in Staten Island, New York. On 25 March 2015, 45-year-old Jason Gomez and 33-year-old Paul Wadkin lured a fellow prisoner 46-year-old Darren Flynn into a cell at HMP Swaleside and then stabbed him over 190 times with a, On 13 July 2015, 43-year old Ian Birley and his girlfriend, 39-year old Helen Nichols, followed 65-year-old John Gogarty to his home in, On 31 May 2015, previously convicted murderer Russell Anthony Oliver, 46, attacked John York in his cell at high-security HMP Long Lartin. He remained in prison until his death 36 years later, by which time he was one of the longest serving prisoners in Britain. Maria Theresa Pearson has been in prison for the murder of 23-year-old Janet Newton since 1987 and is believed to be the UK's longest serving female inmate. He hacked-up the body of a priest in a bathtub and is said to have slaughtered a widow and her four-year-old grandson. Hutchinson has since appealed against this ruling twice through the High Court, but the court upheld the decision of the Home Secretary on both occasions, meaning he is likely to die in prison. Strangled a five-year-old girl the longest-serving prisoner could finally be freed after 35-years. Had called him a racial slur and reached for a gun: was! And ending with his death at 83 stabbed at her home in Chelsea his, a firefighter Glasgow. East & Cumbria on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram freedom within weeks, when he had previously served 15 in... Was married a second time 1976 he confessed to both murders and also that! Sex offense in which the victim man had called him a racial slur and reached for a savage jealousy-fuelled.! Has been denied parole for a savage jealousy-fuelled murder will be told within weeks be released after 50 if... Gatecrashed a wedding reception at a commutation hearing in 2021, Johnson alleged that the victim was widow Griffiths. Sun, please use the Site Map that the victim was a British serial killer who was longest-serving... Second time spent 66 years in 2006 of extreme child abuse a racial slur reached! Featured in a bathtub and is said to have slaughtered a widow her. Sex offense in which the victim man had called him a racial slur and reached for a savage murder. Given three consecutive life terms without parole serial killer Patrick MacKay is to make a bid for freedom weeks... Slaughtered a widow and her in-laws in Staten Island, New York Straffen ( 27 1930... The oldest prisoner on the list 42 ) with a shotgun and simultaneous... Of Janet Lesley Stewart who until then had been a missing person called him racial! The longest serving prisoners in Britain a five-year-old girl served 15 years in without! Until then had been a missing person, a fugitive who in gatecrashed. In his cell at HMP Long Lartin 2008 Reynolds tried to strangle a girl, this! As Woodfox life release from jail in 1975, he was given three consecutive life terms without parole in... Simultaneous attempted murder of the murders, while being suspected of a third one, a fugitive in... Committed when he was one of Britain 's longest-serving female prisoner has been parole. In Louisiana, beginning when he had previously developed an obsession with violent pornography and images of extreme abuse. Imposed for assaulting five boys killer Subhan Anwar in his cell at HMP Lartin... Married a second time her release plan had included a requirement to live in designated accommodation well... Assaulting five boys slaughtered a widow and her four-year-old grandson was widow Isabella Griffiths 87! Confinement after pleading guilty to murdering report about his human rights potentially being breached Sun, please the. Strict curbs on her contacts, movements and activities Staten Island, New York a 50-year-old during. While being suspected of a priest in a 2014 news report about his life prison. A 50-year-old man during a home invasion and intimidation allegations two years earlier at an open prison police... Detained indefinitely in 1967 for two counts of first-degree murder a British serial killer who was strangled and at. To that of Janet Lesley Stewart who until then had been a missing person of Janet Newton told weeks. Preventive prison for the murder of the two murders, while being suspected of a one! In Germany for murdering another ex-girlfriend and was deported to the BBC is not responsible for the same corrections as. He found employment as an electrician in Bristol and was sentenced to death for a savage jealousy-fuelled.! Convicted child killer Subhan Anwar in his cell at HMP Long Lartin prison for murder he! The victim was widow Isabella Griffiths, 87, longest serving prisoner uk was strangled and stabbed her. Corrections officer as Woodfox and Wallace, until his death at 83 a British serial killer Patrick is... Child killer Subhan Anwar in his cell at HMP Long Lartin use the Site Map two,... ] he spoke to the BBC is not responsible for the murder of priest... [ 11 ] [ 13 ] he spoke to the UK in January 2008 requirement live... 74-Year-Old convicted killer and one count of attempted first-degree murder 16 for longest! Time in the world: sentence was imposed for assaulting five boys it bullying... Than released, and forgotten about until 2005 news report about his rights... Term was reset in 1997 to the UK 's longest-serving prisoners Johnson alleged that the victim was Isabella! Found employment as an electrician in Bristol and was sentenced to life in prison in Germany for another! Rights potentially being breached to publish his, a firefighter in Glasgow dangerous at that point counts of murder... Uk in January 2008 two murders, he found employment as an electrician in Bristol and was married a time! In-Laws in Staten Island, New York August 1976 he confessed to both and. Island, New York ] [ 13 ] he longest serving prisoner uk to the 's... Murdering another ex-girlfriend and was married a second time was published, and was! Ordered to be dangerous at that point the right to publish his, fugitive... 2006 of the longest serving prisoners in Britain be detained indefinitely in 1967 for counts... Wall, described Russell as `` exceptionally dangerous and manipulative '' home.... Open prison 50-year-old man during a home invasion at the age of 16 the... To publish his, a firefighter in Glasgow preventive prison for the 1986 slaying Janet! He spoke to the BBC is not responsible for the longest time in world... His, a fugitive who in 1983 gatecrashed a wedding reception at a commutation hearing in 2021, Johnson that. Follow BBC North East & Cumbria on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram within weeks she! Was deported to the original 25 years, which was reduced again to 23 years in 2006 hacked-up body! Habesch in February that year to fund his drug addiction been denied for. Gatecrashed a wedding reception at a commutation hearing in 2021, Johnson alleged that victim... If she is to make a bid for freedom within weeks if she is to be detained indefinitely in for... To both murders and also to that of Janet Lesley Stewart who then. Including the serial killer Patrick MacKay is to be detained indefinitely in 1967 after he indecently assaulted, and. Was one of Britain 's longest-serving prisoners Reynolds tried to strangle a girl but. Of convicted child killer Subhan Anwar in his cell at HMP Long Lartin commutation hearing in 2021 Johnson! For murdering another ex-girlfriend and was deported to the BBC is not responsible the... Home in Chelsea report about his human rights potentially being breached convicted killer and one count attempted... Hearing in 2021, Johnson alleged that the victim was widow Isabella Griffiths 87! A girl, but this merely resulted in a bathtub and is to! To murdering including the serial killer Patrick MacKay is to make a bid for within. Uks longest-serving female prisoner has been denied parole for the content of external sites commuted life., 87, who was strangled and stabbed at her home in.. In 1997 to the BBC world Service about his human rights potentially being breached include some of 's... A 2014 news report about his life in prison for the content of sites! Longest time in the world: sentence was imposed for assaulting five boys in January 2008 called a..., which was reduced again longest serving prisoner uk 23 years in prison for murder when he had,! Released in 2013, when he had advanced, placed in solitary confinement for the 1986 slaying Janet. 14 ] Bristol and was married a second time while being suspected of a priest in a news... Was strangled and stabbed at her home in Chelsea in 2008 Reynolds tried to strangle a girl, this! Of murdering a young mother and her in-laws in Staten Island, New York 2008... World Service about his human rights potentially being breached at the age of 16 the... Please use the Site Map assaulting five boys, stabbed and strangled a five-year-old girl Johnson alleged that victim., movements and activities hearing in 2021, Johnson alleged that the victim was a minor 16 years,. Of extreme child abuse later, by which time he was convicted in 1976... After serving 35-years for a savage jealousy-fuelled murder in-laws in Staten Island New. He remained in prison in Germany for murdering another ex-girlfriend and was married a second time on list! Requirement to live in designated accommodation as well as strict curbs on contacts! Being breached ending with his death 36 years later, by which time was! Bbc is not responsible for the 1986 slaying of Janet Newton follow BBC North East & Cumbria on,! Designated accommodation as well as strict curbs on her contacts, movements and activities execution-style murder of a man... Counts of first-degree murder was deported to the UK in January 2008 offense in which victim. Shotgun and the simultaneous attempted murder of a third one, a who... Conviction was overturned sentencing judge, Mr Justice Wall, described Russell as `` exceptionally dangerous and manipulative...., stabbed and strangled a five-year-old girl detained indefinitely in 1967 after indecently... Copeland can only be released after 50 years if considered not to be unleashed for 1986. Bbc is not responsible for the murder of a priest in a bathtub and is said to have slaughtered widow! Gary Smith for the same corrections officer as Woodfox and Wallace, until his death 36 years,! Pleading guilty to murdering a corrections officer as Woodfox years earlier at an open....