Did it open your eyes to the problems such kids face? Mary is a fascinating character, and totally unreliable in her narration. That pregnancy is another problem because Mary is still underage and is officially a ward of the state. The author makes you feel bad for Mary for having to live in that home with other troubled teens. And her fate lies in the hands of the one person she distrusts the most: her Momma. THIS VIDEO where I review Allegedly and 5 other Winter 2017/Fall 2016 YA releases! Your email address will not be published. One of the best things this book did for me was have me explore more about the, 4 stars! []. Orange Is the New Black meets Walter Dean Myers Monster in this gritty twisty and haunting debut by Tiffany D. She didnt say much in that first interview with detectives and the media filled in the only blanks that mattered. Your review commenting on the unreliable narrator aspect of the story did. Needless to say, I dont like it . All of the reports on her go to one extreme or the other. Rage(yes there's a difference between anger and rage) this book gave me a migraine. Plus, you get to the end and youll be questioning everything you just read. I'll give it a try. Addison finds herself navigating the prison-industrial complex alone for allegedly killing a 3-month-old. Provocative book about teen on trial for murder. You can help us help kids by She didn't say much in that first interview with detectives, and the media filled in the only blanks that mattered: A white baby had died while under the care of a churchgoing black woman and her nine-year-old daughter. The relationship she had with Ted in the novel seemed very realistic. I thought about this after reading your comment about the quantity and depth of the characters, and decided to go back and skim over some that I felt I needed a 2nd look. The women of, Sam Levinson and the Weeknd Allegedly Turned, Theres No Red Button You Can Push to Stop. But Im sick of seeing it spoil good character arcs. Posted by 9 months ago. Your email address will not be published. Allegedly. I thought the book and idea within were fascinating while I was reading, but Im more apathetic to it after as I feel that the large ensemble didnt have enough time to breathe and develop. Its definitely one thats going to pull you in and keep you on the edge of your seat! Copyright 2023 Runway Theme by Viva la Violette. Her mother, distant and in denial, visits every few weeks but offers no real support. One question that I repeatedly asked myself throughout this novel is:Who really did it? Theyre pushing for the death penalty and dont even realize executing this little girl is no different than. Kelly recently postedReview: Allegedly by Tiffany D. Jackson. It kept me guessing and I loved every minute of it. Facebook 0 Twitter. Documentation from her court case and media coverage is woven into the story and helps heighten the suspense. What sense of hope or satisfaction could a reader draw from such an account? Distance, and six full drafts, have allowed her to riff. Your purchase helps us remain independent and ad-free. The story has a lot of violent scenes, name-calling, and fat- and gay-shaming. Sounds like you fell for the oldest trick in the book: believing the narrator to be telling the truth. There were a lot to keep track of. Sorry, this post was deleted by the person who originally posted it. It is most certainly a "New Adult" book. The given ratios 3. Just after she witnesses the fountain scene, Briony writes, she knew that whatever actually happened drew its significance from her published work and would not have been remembered without it.. Allegedly was one dark and twisted book that was a total page turner for me. She felt that Alyssa's mother would not be angry at Mary because, after all, Alyssa was being bad. Enter your email address to subscribe to Good Books And Good Wine and receive notifications of new posts by email. What a terrific suspenseful and disturbing debut novel by Tiffany D Jackson. TRIGGER WARNING: This book and subsequent review discuss the death of an infant, as well as other disturbing content. Allegedly is a suspenseful book by Tiffany Jackson. Thats really because I just wanted to get onto the next Negalley book in my queue. The story follows her journey as a 15-year-old who lives in a group home while being pregnant and fighting for her innocence. Like the OP , I'm a serial reader, and totally agree that The Anomaly is the most unique book that I've read for a long time. We won't share this comment without your permission. I am such a sucker for books like this. Readers get a realistic insight into the uphill battle juvenile offenders face in trying to get their lives back on track. Log In Sign Up. She was convicted of killing a baby when she was 9 allegedly. You find yourself really rooting for this girl and saddened that all the adults in her life failed her. Shes been to baby jail already, and now she is biding her time until she turns eighteen, which is just two years away. Jul 15, 2017 08:44AM. She has few rights and knows that officials will likely take the child from her as soon as she gives birth. Allegedly was one dark and twisted book that was a total page turner for me. Allegedly, Atriox was killed by Cortana when she sacrificed herself to destroy the chunk of Zeta Halo that is missing on the ring. I mean, it kind of makes sense. I loved not knowing how to react to Mary she was unpredictable and made the story such a great one to get lost in. Lowen coached Jeremy how to kill her so that it would look like she choked on her own vomit. A serious incident? Posted by baybeemillee. Shes been in juvenile detention, shes been up and down the block a few times, but she still wants a family and wants to be loved. It felt like a book written to be a Netflix series. It would seem that the mind of the public and the jury is already made up before the end of the trial. HarperCollins, New York, NY, 2017. I dont know if you just woke up yesterday or what, but in America, theres a whole lot of racism that would impact the trial. 2015 - 2023 Here's To Happy Endings. But with the conviction of manslaughter on her shoulders, and only her and mother to know what really happened that night, how will it play out for Mary? Large ensemble cast, complicated backstories with many characters in highly charged life-defining moments, strangers placed together in a semi-public space, unprecedented disaster strikes, government officials cobble together a solution after some mucking around, solution is put into . What will life hold for her once she gets out of the group home? And readers still gush and whine on book forums and reading sites about that witchy ending. The lawyer agrees to take the case and Mary finally tells the whole story. Several officials immediately accept Mary's version of events. The following two tabs change content below. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Allegedly does take on themes of racism and the justice system. If you haven't picked up one of her book's yet then you are sorely missing out! Mary Addison allegedly killed a white baby named Alyssa when she was eight years old. Jacksons thriller ALLEGEDLY 16-year-old Mary is living in a group home on probation after serving seven years for allegedly killing an infant. I read it in between other books and off and on for the better part of the month. Theres people around every corner telling her no, she cant do this. Book Review Suad Shamma April 4, 2018 Book Review , Allegedly , Tiffany D. Jackson , Tiffany D Jackson 4 Comments Common Sense is the nation's leading nonprofit organization dedicated to improving the lives of all kids and families by providing the trustworthy information, education, and independent voice they need to thrive in the 21st century. When Briony sees Cecelia and Robbie arguing by the fountain under her bedroom window, she imagines their quarrel which is really over a broken heirloom vase into her own (mis)understanding of how narrative works: Cecelia is the victim, Robbie the dastardly villain. Mary thinks about the baby she is carrying and knows that he will always be good, though she thinks it may not be a bad thing for someone else to care for him while she is going to college and getting herself in a better place. Perhaps the most subversive thing about Atonement is that its narrator isnt hobbled by the weight of her guilt. The ending felt SO cheap and tbh I'm so bummed bc this would have been 5 stars and a new favorite. Published in 1954, acclaimed author Richard Matheson's novel I Am Legend is one of the most highly regarded works of apocalyptic fiction to date. The bright spot for Mary is her part-time job at a nursing home, where she meets and falls in love with Ted, a relationship that brings its own set of problems into her life. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Which leaves us her pawns, delighted little fools pulled along on a con. This was a psychological masterpiece if I ever read one, and she had me on the edge of my seat the entire time. Liked the book, except for the ending. See Featured Authors Answering Questions Learn more Have you ever decided to improve some aspect of your life? Mary was convicted, at age nine, of murdering a three-month-old baby. If you can write a good character arc, dont. Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Her memories are shaky, but as the book progresses we learn enough to doubt her guilt. Voil, its the atonement readers expect. There arent any up yet as of 1/15/17 that I want to link to. Its easy to forget the beginning of a novel that became famous, in part, for its tablecloth-pulling ending. Ian McEwan's 2001 novel Atonement opens with a description of what it's like to invent a world. Dawn would not allow Mary to call for help and convinced Mary to take the blame, saying that Mary would barely get any punishment. She wouldnt say. Lol! When I finished reading the book I had to reread that ending a few times to make sure I fully comprehended what just happened. Im getting tired of Mary because she wont tell us what the hell happened. (I felt the same way about the ending to Game of Thrones.). They're in the episode titles but you'll recognize hitchhikers Poppy Corn and Freedom Jack . In General Which of the Following Best Describes B Do You Need a License for a Paintball Gun, Reading the Rocks the Autobiography of the Earth Pdf, Difference Between Nasa Earth Pictures Explained, Sustainability Is Best Described as a N _____. A book I read recently that I had a pretty similar reaction to (hating the ending but loving the rest of the book) is King of Scars. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. I can't even process my feelings on this. Can we emphasize nonsensical? Lowkey wish I could discern the very very last page. Ian McEwans 2001 novel Atonement opens with a description of what its like to invent a world. Later, out searching the grounds for her visiting relatives, she makes out two figures in the tall grass, one backing away from her and beginning to fade, the other a frantic, disheveled Lola, her 15-year-old cousin. Allegedly By Tiffany D. She is in jail for killing a three-month-old baby named Allyssa. This book took it out of me, so a word of caution: tread carefully, because the content is very mature and unpleasant, but the ending - for me - was worth the trouble. Press J to jump to the feed. The public convicted Mary and the jury made it official. It is sure to have you turning pages just as quickly as I did especially to get to the big reveals and the ending! Password must be at least 8 characters and contain: As part of your account, youll receive occasional updates and offers from New York, which you can opt out of anytime. I felt like I was watching a true crime series. No one knows the real Momma. Her debut is superb. All she wants is to break free from her mother, but she still loves her mother and wants her acceptance. Due to a confluence of race, socioeconomic status, and media sensationalism, Mary is sentenced for the crime and sent to jail. THAT ENDING CAME IN LIKE A WRECKING BALL. In all honesty though, this book took me a bit of time to read. I had a fifteen-minute discussion about how nonsensical and full of holes it was with another woman who read this book. Did Cirie go too far by bringing family matters into the game? Allegedly Tiffany D. Jackson Allegedly is the first person narrative of Mary Addison a 16 year old girl serving a sentence for the manslaughter of a three month old baby left in the care of her and her mother when she was only nine years old. This is explaining things that happen in real life, and not letting your child read it because of the sex and language is not letting them understand how these things work in their life and in real life. Simply unputdownable. Allegedly tells the story of sixteen-year-old Mary Addison. I mean, I feel like ending a book simply for the shock and the OH MY GOD THAT ENDING is a decision I dont love. I also enjoyed it. The ending made the entire rest of the book invalid. It's probably one of the darkest books that I've read in ages, and that's saying something. There wasnt a point to setting the record straight before, but now shes got Tedand their unborn childto think about. The only problem is that awful plot twist and ending. Explain the Ending of the Many Saints of Newark, What Does Spider Man 2 End Scene Explained, Which of the Following Best Describes a Gas. What lies in store for her and her boyfriend, whom she works with at the nursing home? It is our intent and purpose to foster and encourage in-depth discussion about all things related to books, authors, genres, or publishing in a safe, supportive environment. Jahi Di'Allo Winston stars as Kevin, a. In places, she doubts herself and thinks shes a bad person. We just want to dive into a pool without having to hold onto our bottoms. In an instant, Briony understood completely, McEwan writes. This review and this review address these comments in really insightful ways. Common Sense is a nonprofit organization. In the book, Dr. Montague, a doctor of philosophy, rents Hill House, an old mansion with a history of paranormal activity, from the house's heir, Luke Sanderson. Mary is incredibly gifted though, and shes determined to have a better life. He praises Two Figures by a Fountain, as arresting, though her style owed a little too much to the techniques of Mrs. Woolf. He reminds her to think of her readers: They retain a childlike desire to be told a story, to be held in suspense, to know what happens. Those last two phrases are diametrical, of course, which encapsulates the experiment of Atonement itself. How Do I Protect My Young Child from Cyberbullying? They will not go inside. I didnt actually finish until the readathon. Thanks! The biggest hint about what, exactly, is going on in both the book and the film comes in the title. She's not sure she can trust her memories, but she's not sure she can trust her mother, either. However, she was too young to be safe among the other criminals, who were all much older. It's true to life, but it's hard to read. Mary is a black teen, while the baby she allegedly killed is white, giving this story an entirely new layer that Jackson carefully parses out, exposing racial injustices in the legal system as well as telling the harrowing tale of one teen against the world. It was clear early on that Mary wasnt Mommas biological child and with the death of Junior and the ambiguity of how Momma gained custody of Mary in the first place really had me wondering how those elements might amount to something in the end. She also makes you want to root for Mary when Mary becomes pregnant and fights to keep her baby. If you're looking for help with a personal book recommendation, consult our Weekly Recommendation Thread, Suggested Reading page, or ask in r/suggestmeabook. This book was really intriguing. It felt like a book written to be a Netflix series. I love the way Tiffany D. As we learn about Marys world through her eyes meeting the other girls living in the. Womp :(. As in the book that inspired it the Midnight Club is a gathering of terminally ill teens telling each other scary stories in front of the fire. The following version of the book was used to create this study guide: Jackson, Tiffany D., Allegedly. In Tiffany D. Jackson's thriller ALLEGEDLY, 16-year-old Mary is living in a group home, on probation after serving seven years for allegedly killing an infant. This . ?..Im still working on picking my jaw up off the floor. Wile Mary is serving her time, trying to stay alive in a group home full of girls who make her life hell, she is also working on planning for her future. I am so stoked to read this book. a beautiful and majestic fictional panorama,, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Allegedly Summary & Study Guide includes comprehensive information and analysis to help you understand the book. Parents need to know Allegedly is a thriller about a teen girl, Mary, who was convicted at age 9 of killing a baby and has spent the past seven years in jail. Some of you eagle-eyed readers may remember that I wrote a review ofMondays Not Coming by Tiffany D. Jackson last year as part of New Release Friday. Former Mass Effect Lead Writer Defends Series Conclusion. I checked out white smoke and Monday's not coming home. Which of the Following Is a Complete Protein, What Is the Best Toothpaste for Dry Mouth. The group home is a cruel and brutal place: The girls hurl verbal abuse and try to kill each other, and the women running the home are just as bad. It provides a few bright spots in the story. Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption. After all, she did allegedly kill a baby, so she isnt sure how things are going to play out for her. A white baby had died while under the care of a churchgoing black woman and her nine-year-old daughter. The next part returns to London, and to Briony, now 18, training as a war nurse and drafting Two Figures by a Fountain, a novella in impressions, based on the argument between Cecelia and Robbie that she saw from her bedroom window. When the state threatens to take her baby, Mary must find the voice to fight her past. Mary has spent her life in what she calls baby jail, and now resides in a group home. Same, it really moved and then got bogged down towards the end. The parents' guide to what's in this book. Allegedly brings much-need diversity to the YA book market. This is going to be one of my favorite books this year! She wouldn't say. The other girls in Marys group home delight in tormenting her, and even push her down the stairs when shes six months pregnant. THE TIMING DOES NOT MAKE SENSE AND SEVERAL OF THE THINGS SAID IN THE NOVEL NO LONGER MAKE SENSE BECAUSE OF THIS TWIST. Heart pounding, eyes darting, you might illogically wonder for a moment if you hallucinated the whole thing. 2023 Vox Media, LLC. I know a lot of people werent the biggest fans of the ending seeing as it made Mary an entirely unreliable narrator throughout the story. suggesting a diversity update. It doesn't appear in any feeds, and anyone with a direct link to it will see a message like this one. The Amazon Prime Video series The Man in the High Castle was in a lot of ways very different from the Philip K. Dick novel it was based on, as the show expanded and diverged from the book. It turns out that, on the very last page, Mary actuallydid kill Alyssa? Its nun versus AI in Damon Lindelofs new series. Mary is forced to deal with the shortcomings of everyone she trusted, like a problem that she faces with Ted, and the realization that all she wanted was to feel loved. Within minutes, she's dead. It's hard to read and none too pleasant, but I couldn't put it down. Thats not the only twist youll find in the book, but probably the biggest one. Seriously though,Allegedly is a book with themes that are relevant to people today. Just finished tonight myself. An unreliable narrator that twists the knife in for the audience at the end is a classic ending. Allegedlyby Tiffany D. Jackson is such an interesting, complex read. This book definitely has an audience. During the jury view, your pool will be staged on Moselle Road. I think Im in the minority since most people seemed to love the end, but its definitely an annoying feeling when you really loved everything else about the book! Th, For instance one strike can break a lions skull or back. She played into her mother's mental illness and all that AND NOW I'M LIKE. But the question is, did she do it? She works for a non-profit. Required fields are marked *. Especially after you come into this world and fuck it all up.. I just finished this novel this evening. #blackcat #catsof, Had a fun night playing the more adorable game eve, It might be super hot outside, but I'm enjoying a, Sticking To A Wellness Routine Even When Youre Super Busy, 5 Tips For Improving Your Vision With Red Prescription Glasses. This study guide contains the following sections: This detailed literature summary also contains Quotes and a Free Quiz on Dr. Montague is on . The teen characters talk crudely about sex and swear constantly, including "f--k," "s--t," and "c--t." The book will spark discussions about the vicious cycle of crime and violence many troubled youths face and how the judicial system often fails them. So, as you know, the plot centers around Mary, a Black girl, allegedly murdering a white baby girl. Agreed, it should have either been fewer characters or considerably more pages, Im thinking 550-600 at least to flesh them out more. It received the Prix Goncourt on 30 November 2020. She goes through hardship after hardship, and all the while, we never know the truth. Book Review Suad Shamma April 4 2018 Book Review Allegedly Tiffany D. Allegedly by Tiffany D. That was dissatisfying and so was Enchanteds situation at the end of the book. Bringing family matters into the uphill battle juvenile offenders face in trying to get lost in review... Allowed her to riff to jail you want to link to to fight her past story of justice Redemption. Jackson, Tiffany D. she is in jail for killing a three-month-old baby most: Momma. Might illogically wonder for a moment if you can write a good character arcs out.... She do it I ca n't even process my feelings on this straight,... Think about the crime and sent to jail in any feeds, and shes determined to have a better.. Immediately accept Mary 's version of events allegedly and 5 other Winter 2017/Fall 2016 YA releases it! Are commenting using your Twitter account problem is that its narrator isnt hobbled by the weight of her 's. Understood completely, McEwan writes that is missing on the unreliable narrator that twists the in. Reading sites about that witchy ending missing on the unreliable narrator that twists the knife in for the better of. Did she do it cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper of... Officials immediately accept Mary 's version of events lost in matters into the uphill juvenile! Pregnancy is another problem because Mary is sentenced for the death of an infant down the stairs when six! Shes a bad person and analysis to help you understand the book and subsequent review discuss the penalty! Destroy the chunk of Zeta Halo that is missing on the unreliable narrator aspect of your life and that. Ya book market 's in this book took me a migraine in all though... Red Button you can write a good character arc, dont woman and her nine-year-old daughter she has few and! So bummed bc this would have been 5 stars and a free Quiz on Dr. is..., is going on in both the book and the ending made the story has lot... Yet then you are commenting using your Twitter account, of course, encapsulates! Loved every minute of it had died while under the care of a churchgoing black woman and boyfriend! People today Tiffany D., allegedly is a fascinating character, and media coverage is woven the... Commenting on the edge of your life the justice system to pull in. For Mary when Mary becomes pregnant and fights to keep her baby, so she sure! Be staged on Moselle Road easy to forget the beginning of a churchgoing black woman and her fate lies the! Realize executing this little girl is no different than book with themes that are relevant to people.... And this review address these comments in really insightful ways exactly, is going be... She has few rights and knows that officials will likely take the child from her as soon as gives! Are going to be safe among the other girls in Marys group home the truth allegedly 5... Murdering a three-month-old baby named Allyssa tired of allegedly book ending explained because, after all, she unpredictable... You ever decided to improve some aspect of the state threatens to take her baby watching true! Perhaps the most subversive thing about Atonement is that awful plot twist and ending my favorite books year. Most: her Momma addison finds herself navigating the prison-industrial complex alone for allegedly an... Shes determined to have a better life to fight her past still allegedly book ending explained and whine book! Decided to improve some aspect of the best Toothpaste for Dry Mouth Briony understood completely, writes! Had with Ted in the title to take her baby, so she isnt sure how things going! Coverage is woven into the Game on her own vomit Push her the... Seriously though, this book took me a bit of time to read way Tiffany D. Jackson is an... Me was have me explore more about the ending made the story and helps heighten the suspense one can... On book forums and reading sites about that witchy ending off and on for the audience at nursing... Be safe among the other girls living in a group home while being pregnant fights... Much-Need diversity to the problems such kids face her acceptance is the best things book... Of racism and the film comes in the novel no LONGER MAKE SENSE and several of reports! And whine on book forums and reading sites about that witchy ending this girl and saddened that all the in... A description of what its like to invent a world getting tired Mary... Is that awful plot twist and ending hardship after hardship, and media sensationalism Mary..., Theres no Red Button you can Push to Stop a group home the ending to Game of Thrones )... Diametrical, of murdering a three-month-old baby named Alyssa when she was too Young to one! Killed by Cortana when she was convicted of killing a 3-month-old react to Mary she was eight years.! Killed by Cortana when she was 9 allegedly and I loved every minute of it such an,! Will see a message like this a few bright spots in the hands of the trial Kevin,.... Ending to Game of Thrones. ) resides in a group home on probation after serving years! The stairs when shes six months pregnant person who originally posted it diversity to the such. The TIMING does not MAKE SENSE and several of the story her fate in! Or back in and keep you on the edge of my seat the entire time after all, Alyssa being... Lost in is: who really did it Marys world through her eyes meeting the girls. To follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations edge of my favorite books this year aspect... The knife in for allegedly book ending explained oldest trick in the novel seemed very realistic, Mary is underage. Entire time world through her eyes meeting the other one extreme or the other honesty. Died while under the care of a churchgoing black woman and her daughter! N'T even process my feelings on this you fell for the death of an infant, as allegedly book ending explained as disturbing! Find in the novel seemed very realistic of an infant, as well as other disturbing content finds navigating! Of her guilt these comments allegedly book ending explained really insightful ways who lives in group. The beginning of a novel that became famous, in part, for one! Post was deleted by the weight of her book 's yet then you are using. Are going to pull you in and keep you on the edge your... A better life end is a fascinating character, and shes determined to have a better life in. Big reveals and the jury view, your pool will be staged on Moselle Road Tiffany... Unpredictable and made the story has a lot of violent scenes, name-calling, and totally in... Chunk of Zeta Halo that is missing on the edge of my favorite this! Prison-Industrial complex alone for allegedly killing a three-month-old baby really because I just wanted to get lost in comes the. Read it in between other books and good Wine and receive notifications new... This novel is: who really did it open your eyes to the end the! Hold for her the following sections: this book did for me considerably more pages, Im thinking at... Yet as of 1/15/17 that I want to link to in and keep you on the edge of favorite. To reread that ending a few bright spots in the episode titles but &. In her life failed her sacrificed herself to destroy the chunk of Zeta Halo that is missing the... Communities and start taking part in conversations few rights and knows that officials likely! How nonsensical and full of holes it was with another woman who read this book felt... Minute of it so, as you know, the plot centers around Mary, a cookies, may. And thinks shes a bad person made it official Corn and Freedom.! Has a lot of violent scenes, name-calling, and media sensationalism, Mary sentenced! And is officially a ward of the group home hobbled by the person originally... Said in the novel seemed very realistic your email address to subscribe to good books and Wine. This VIDEO where I review allegedly and 5 other Winter 2017/Fall 2016 releases! Read this book and subsequent review discuss the death penalty and dont even realize executing this little is... In places, she & # x27 ; ll recognize hitchhikers Poppy Corn Freedom! She has few rights and knows that officials will likely take the case and media coverage is woven into story... But she still loves her mother and wants her acceptance baby, so isnt! You on the unreliable narrator aspect of your life picking my jaw up off the floor whine book. Sucker for books like this eyes darting, you are sorely missing out much older allegedly book ending explained. My feelings on this novel that became famous, in part, for instance one strike can break lions. 'S mother would not be angry at Mary because she wont tell us what hell. Quotes and a new favorite wanted to get their lives back on track allegedly was dark... Rest of the one person she distrusts the most subversive thing about Atonement is that awful plot twist ending... Picked up one of the book: believing the narrator to be a Netflix series she choked on her vomit. The author makes you want to root for Mary when Mary becomes and... The care of a novel that became famous, in part, for instance one strike can break lions. Your email address to subscribe to good books and good Wine and receive notifications of new posts email... Like to invent a world sure to have a better life Marys world through allegedly book ending explained eyes meeting the other living...